Negotiating What Is Said in the Face of Miscommunication

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)peer-review


In post-Gricean pragmatics, communication is said to be successful when a hearer recovers a speaker’s intended message. On this assumption, proposals for ‘what is said’ – the semantic, propositional meaning of a speaker’s utterance – are typically centred around the content the speaker aimed to communicate. However, these proposals tend not to account for the fact that speakers can be deliberately vague leaving no clear proposition to be recovered, or that a speaker can accept a hearer’s misconstrual even though the speaker didn’t intend it. In such cases, identifying ‘what is said’ is more contentious, even though communication is arguably no less successful. Building on recent interactionist approaches to meaning, this chapter offers a proposal for ‘what is said’ that can account for cases of ‘imperfect’ communication in which the recovery of a speaker’s intention goes awry. This involves taking ‘what is said’ as the co-constructed meaning that the speaker and hearer jointly agree on, giving ‘grounded meanings’ – those mutually and manifestly accepted into the discourse by speaker and hearer – higher precedence in a theory of communication than simply the speaker’s intended meaning. In such cases, rather than speaker and hearer converging at the level of explicit utterance content, communication is expected to be successful just in case the hearer recovers a proposition which is compatible with the speaker’s higher-order discursive goal. The hearer’s uptake is then allowed to override the content of the speaker’s intended meaning in the process of negotiating ‘what is said’.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationPhilosophical Insights into Pragmatics
EditorsPiotr Stalmaszczyk
PublisherDe Gruyter
ISBN (Electronic)9783110628937
Publication statusPublished - May 2019

Publication series

NamePhilosophical Analysis
PublisherDe Gruyter
ISSN (Print)2198-2066
ISSN (Electronic)2198-2074

Cite this