Question design in nurse-led and GP-led telephone triage for same-day appointment requests: a comparative investigation

J. Murdoch, R. Barnes, J. Pooler, V. Lattimer, E. Fletcher, J. L. Campbell

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

13 Citations (Scopus)
6 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Objective: To compare doctors’ and nurses’ communication with patients in primary care telephone triage consultations.
Design: Qualitative comparative study of content and form of questions in 51 telephone triage encounters between practitioners (general practitioners (GPs)=29; nurses=22) and patients requesting a same-day appointment in primary care. Audio-recordings of nurse-led calls were synchronised with video recordings of nurse's use of computer decision support software (CDSS) during triage.
Setting: 2 GP practices in Devon and Warwickshire, UK.
Participants: 4 GPs and 29 patients; and 4 nurses and 22 patients requesting a same-day face-to-face appointment with a GP.
Main outcome measure: Form and content of practitioner-initiated questions and patient responses during clinical assessment.
Results: A total of 484 question–response sequences were coded (160 GP; 324 N). Despite average call lengths being similar (GP=4 min, 37 s, (SD=1 min, 26 s); N=4 min, 39 s, (SD=2 min, 22 s)), GPs and nurses differed in the average number (GP=5.51, (SD=4.66); N=14.72, (SD=6.42)), content and form of questions asked. A higher frequency of questioning in nurse-led triage was found to be due to nurses’ use of CDSS to guide telephone triage. 89% of nurse questions were oriented to asking patients about their reported symptoms or to wider-information gathering, compared to 54% of GP questions. 43% of GP questions involved eliciting patient concerns or expectations, and obtaining details of medical history, compared to 11% of nurse questions. Nurses using CDSS frequently delivered questions designed as declarative statements requesting confirmation and which typically preferred a ‘no problem’ response. In contrast, GPs asked a higher proportion of interrogative questions designed to request information.
Conclusions: Nurses and GPs emphasise different aspects of the clinical assessment process during telephone triage. These different styles of triage have implications for the type of information available following nurse-led or doctor-led triage, and for how patients experience triage.
Original languageEnglish
Article numbere004515
JournalBMJ Open
Volume4
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 5 Mar 2014

Cite this