The malignancy grading method is not a reliable assessment of malignancy in mesothelioma

The ploidy of a series of pleural lesions--reactive proliferations, malignant mesotheliomas and metastatic tumours--was measured on a Leitz Miamed DNA image analyser using Feulgen-stained slides. The technique successfully recognized all the metastatic tumours as malignant; this corresponds to previous work. However, it was not successful in classifying mesothelial lesions as benign or malignant, resulting in a very high false-negative rate and a moderately high false-positive rate. Mesothelial lesions appear to have a wide range of ploidy values irrespective of their biological behaviour. Thus, for primary mesothelial tumours, the ploidy value cannot be used as a reliable diagnostic index.